It had happened only once since 9/11: on Friday, in the United States, all civilian aircraft remained grounded for several hours.*
The FAA (Federal Aviation Administration) invoked the precautionary principle after a “telecommunications outage.”
The agency falls under the Department of Transportation, headed by Sean Duffy. He did not mince his words: yes, the air traffic control system is obsolete, he acknowledged, pointing to “analog equipment decades old.”
The situation is similar in France. The Cour des comptes reminded of this this summer. While focused on the human resources policy of the Directorate General for Civil Aviation (DGAC), its analysis highlights modernization needs—and the delays in the programs launched for this purpose.
The Troubles of SYSAT and 4-Flight, the Two Major Modernization Programs
In France, five CRNA (centres en route de la navigation aérienne) manage the upper airspace. To modernize them, notably the 4-Flight program is underway. Launched in 2011, it aims to generalize stripless control (no paper strips).
SYSAT (Système approche et tour) began in the same year to modernize the 79 control towers and 28 approach facilities that handle takeoffs and landings.
The Cour des comptes is far from the first to sound the alarm. In 2023, for example, the Senate Finance Committee published a scathing report on these two projects, noting they had “accumulated setbacks in terms of delays and financial overruns.”
4-Flight was then in service only in two CRNAs, whereas it was originally supposed to be fully deployed by 2015. Its projected costs had nearly doubled, rising from €450 million to €885 million. The Coflight system – a companion system for the automatic processing of flight plans – followed the same trajectory, increasing from €153 million to €310 million.
The Paris region component of SYSAT had to be completely restructured in 2021 due to over-specification that had ruled out any existing product. The provincial component proved unfeasible, envisaging modernization of all control towers by 2020.
The rapporteur (Vincent Capo-Canellas, senator for Seine-Saint-Denis) had already sounded the alarm in 2018. He observed that French air traffic control was “20 years behind” its counterparts and that it was the continent’s main source of delays. It suffered then from governance shortcomings and difficulties within the DTI (Direction de la Technique et de l’Innovation), “too inward-looking.”
A Sometimes Unfavorable Social Climate
The Reims and Aix CRNAs were the first to switch to 4-Flight, at the end of 2022. The Athis-Mons one did so in early 2025. All three had previously used paper strips. The other two (Brest, Bordeaux) operate an internally developed digital interface.
The coexistence with the old CAUDRA system, developed in the 1960s, has complicated interactions among CRNAs. It also lengthened training times during staff moves. In Bordeaux, implementation is more difficult due to its coincidence with another project, NVCS (New Voice Communication System), which aims to replace radio-telephony chains dating from the 1990s. On site, internal experts describe the new workstations as incomplete. Their operations were met with strikes by some technical staff, blocking modernization. Numerous disputes were brought before the administrative tribunal on this subject, notes the Cour des comptes.
This situation weighed on Bordeaux air traffic controllers, who operated in a reduced team for more than three years. Nearly a third were deployed to instruct their colleagues on 4-Flight. The dispute found a resolution in October 2025 with the signing of an agreement with the social and administrative committee. It notably provides for compensation days for flexible work and modernization bonuses.
The Question of 4-Flight’s Obsolescence Is Already Raised
The focus on large modernization programs had sidelined the obsolescence of other systems, the Senate Finance Committee noted. It estimated a technological debt of €700 million accumulated. It called for thinking about what would come after 4-Flight. It concluded that the program did not have a long-term future, having not been designed on a sustainable IT architecture.
The Cour des comptes nonetheless notes regarding 4-Flight that the latest versions do not offer certain functionalities in place in other countries. For example: a device that would alert conflicts with the trajectory of another aircraft by projecting the effect of a captain’s piloting settings or a controller’s instruction.
Obsolescence is more broadly manifested by “poorer ergonomics.” Controllers must consult multiple screens, manually verify data, and project or cross-check information themselves that could be centralized and equipped with automatic alarms.
* With the exception of “a few medical, humanitarian, and law enforcement flights.”